May 13th, 2013
05:20 PM ET

Managing success: Man City right to ax Mancini?

From left to right: Roberto Di Matteo, Alex Ferguson, Roberto Mancini and Luciano Spalletti. (Getty Images)
From left to right: Roberto Di Matteo, Alex Ferguson, Roberto Mancini and Luciano Spalletti. (Getty Images)

As the end of another UEFA Champions League campaign draws to a climactic close, it’s traditional to assess those that stood above others with their contribution of exceptional performance, inspired tactics and delivery of dramatic moments.

The ritual of placing an outstanding player or masterful manager on a pedestal to marvel at their achievements is an annual exercise of adulation, but there is a flip side to the tale of the season that this ignores.

Tradition, according to Christian scholar Jaroslav Jan Pelikan, is “the living faith of the dead”, and so - with this thought as a guiding light - this column will focus on the negative and malfunctioning instead. Namely, which manager failed most to live-up to their pre-season goals? After all, this is the question that preoccupies the myriad of club owners across Europe.

Failure can be so subjective, so potentially the best bar to provide a measure of successless shepherds is to focus on the value for money they gave back to their sides. If transfer spending against progress in Europe’s top club competition is mapped the following four were rightly in the firing line*:

4. Alex Ferguson – Manchester United:
He may have been the greatest manager to grace British football and a two-time winner of the Champions League but "Fergie" had seen diminishing returns from his forays into Europe in the last two seasons of his tenure. A sizeable $103m were spent over the last campaign bringing in players such as goal-getter Robin Van Persie and goal-stopper David De Gea.

In return United failed at the group stages last year and were knocked out before the quarterfinals in 2013. No wonder the great Scot was left devastated by the Real Madrid defeat this time around, by his own standards the Red Devils had not delivered. Future – Retires at end of season

3. Roberto Mancini – Manchester City:
The blue half of Manchester are relative newcomers to Champions League combat, so that may be a mitigating factor for failure, but what they lacked in experience they surely made up for in player spending power. An outlay of over $230m in the last two seasons by Italian coach Roberto Mancini, not to mention the capture of the English Premier League title, had seen expectations soar as high as the players’ wage bill at Eastlands. And sadly, for their followers, this campaign saw the disappointment of a winless group stage and stunted progress in Europe once again.

Jack Rodwell, Maicon, Scott Sinclair, Matja Nastasic and Javi Garcia were all brought to the club for $84m but failed to propel the Sky Blues past the group stages at the second time of asking. Mancini’s critics will point to his limited success with Inter Milan in the same competition too. The timing and delivery of the termination may have been less than tender but is it any wonder the owners decided to wield the axe?*
Future – Unemployed after being sacked by City

2. Luciano Spalletti – Zenit St. Petersburg:
The 54-year-old Italian manager joined the Russian side in 2009 but in a show of enhanced ambition the national champions splashed out $140m in the last year on player firepower, including the signings of such luminaries as Brazilian striker Hulk and Alex Witsel of Belgium.

Despite such investment, and with promise to be the dark horses with designs on shaking up the old order, Zenit flattered to deceive. They notched up just two wins in six groups games, with Hulk scoring only once in five outings, and conceded nine. As club captain Danny concluded at the end of the campaign: "Considering the quality we have in this team we could have done much better." Future – Linked to Chelsea, Roma and AC Milan

1. Roberto Di Matteo – Chelsea:
Never before have the reigning champions of Europe been booted out of the competition at the first opportunity, but such was the fate of 2012’s unlikely title-holders from London. The football world marvelled at the ability of the 42-year-old manager Di Matteo to cajole a dispirited team and defeat the mighty Bayern Munich in last year’s final.

It then scratched its head in disbelief as the Italian’s - albeit inherited - team failed to fire despite over $153m of investment in the last 12 months. Di Matteo was dumped from the club shortly before Chelsea were dumped out the group stage. Whoever takes over next season will be expected to considerably improve on that return. Future – Currently unemployed

*Updates made in light of the sacking of Roberto Mancini by Manchester City.

soundoff (10 Responses)
  1. Nikola

    Fergie the worst? no, he is the best by beating Real Madrid with an average team! you should make a poll with worst ref in the Champions League, we all know who is getting that one.

    May 13, 2013 at 6:35 pm | Reply
  2. Elia

    I think Mourinho should have made the list. He has not been successful in Europe with Madrid.

    May 13, 2013 at 6:43 pm | Reply
  3. dion

    im not convinced Sir Alex should be included amongst the flop list. in this season's exit, Man Utd were hard done by. A contentious referee decision to say the least. 9 out of 10 pundits believe Nani should not have received a straight red, which ultimately paved the way to Real snatching victory. Fergies European consistency over his tenure is second to none. Granted he should have sown up more titles however at this level the margins are so slight anything can happen.

    May 13, 2013 at 10:45 pm | Reply
  4. dennis

    Fergie on this list ? Does this guy ever watch football ? Stick to baseball mate . Chelsea fan

    May 14, 2013 at 1:17 pm | Reply
  5. nin

    why the hell is fergie on that list ahah and mourinho is a great coach, he has turned 3 of the worst clubs ever into champions...smh

    May 14, 2013 at 1:56 pm | Reply
  6. nurbudisaputro

    Reblogged this on SixFiveNinetyTwo.

    May 14, 2013 at 4:09 pm | Reply
  7. omegafifteen

    Even if Mancini has still a long way to go for becoming one of the best coaches, he's still a very good coach.
    This article seems to me more like a Nationalistic propaganda by the British Sport Press Association in favor of the local coaches.

    May 16, 2013 at 11:38 pm | Reply
  8. pramok

    Yes certainly Fergie..... maybe the domestic league came luckily but Man UTD. were beaten by Chelsea both times and he has left behind a very mediocre ageing side that has to be rebuilt all over again... I hope he is not doing this to be recalled all over again in his late years..... He should have gone long long time ago and made ways for younger new generation play ....

    May 18, 2013 at 1:31 am | Reply
  9. kodlis

    i dont think fergie should be on that list, but if i want to vote then the worst is mancini-spalletti-di mateo-barcelona coach in this champions legue

    May 20, 2013 at 2:02 pm | Reply
  10. damian

    fergie should not be on that list. Mourinho should be in your list

    May 29, 2013 at 7:42 pm | Reply

Post a comment


CNN welcomes a lively and courteous discussion as long as you follow the Rules of Conduct set forth in our Terms of Service. Comments are not pre-screened before they post. You agree that anything you post may be used, along with your name and profile picture, in accordance with our Privacy Policy and the license you have granted pursuant to our Terms of Service.