Typical americans. If you win their US CUP (several times) you must be the best player ever.

Of course Roger Federer is the BEST EVER EVER!

Rafa is My Idol...is wonderfull

Is this supposed to be a professionally written article? It seems more like an amateur blog to me – where is the analytical reasoning, or indepth coverage of this subject, or insight?

Patience people. Young Toro is moving along nicely, but the next 5 years will tell. There are 3 levels of greatness: 1-5 slams, 6-10 slams and 11 plus slams. GOAT candidates necessarily come from the top tier and all of the following merit consideration: Laver, Borg, Sampras, Emerson and, of course, Federer. Roger is nearing the end of his run and we can only hope that he starts charging the net relentlessly, otherwise he will struggle to get to 18. His fate now rests in his willingness to listen to Paul Annacone and accept that staying back with these young fellows is no longer the best option, especially at Flushing Meadow.

He is not the best but he will be. In Spain we love him not only because he is a great player but also he is a good person too. I wish you the best Rafa!!! you deserve it.

Rafa shows perfection in tennis, added with perfection as a human being, he's the young gentleman and the best possible promotion for tennis. Rafa will live forever in our minds, even in the 22th century people will still remeber Rafael Nadal! Congrats Rafa!!

Anthonie/Netherlands

Rafa, put so much into each point played, its insane, That's why I love watching him, OK, with a few heart tablets ready. But the way he improved his serve so short before the Open, is awesome, and not something anybody can do.

Rafa is not nearly the same as Fedex, Rafa is humble, polite and a all round good innocent person.

Fedex on the other hand, can be mean, I have seen him shouting at Novak's parents some time back at RG, (OK the 2 dont like each other) but Roger can do with a bit humality, he is full of himself.

Give me Rafa anyday. Beautiful from inside and out. Vamos from South Africa.

Both Nadal and Federer are truly great players, but I believe Nadal is far superior to Federer. Federer is a great player because he is played in an era when the world hadn't produced great players.

Nadal has certainly shown Federer who is boss, and would have been a serious threat to great players like Sampras, Lendl, Agassi, etc.,had he played in their era.

I am not saying this because I am an American. I am stating this because Sampras, Becker, Agassi, Edberg, are all great players and had to contend amongst each other, as well as other top contenders. McEnroe had to contend with Bjorg, Lendl, Wilander, and other top players.

Federer is good but highly over rated. If you think Baghdatis, Tsonga, Soderling, Roddick, and Gonzalez are great contenders, then you are nuts.

Rafa is a great tennis player, a humble person and thats you best quality. I wish you only the best. Se te quiere Rafa, desde Panamá.

Isn't it annoying to ask about best ever regarding tennis and plainly wrong? Tennis is ever growing, and who will be the best in 10 years will be probably best ever, because he or she will play better than all his or her predecessors, just because tennis will be better, stronger, more precise. Don't forget that Martina Navratilova played with a wooden racket. Now, if you say Federer is one of the best because he has the most titles, well maybe others have not been that good during his reign.

Rafa it is not the best of the history but he is the number one at present.
Rafa is an example not only for Spaniards but everybody.
Thank you very much Rafa!!
We love you

When did trying hard for every point make you not the best player! Rafa won in a domineering way and seems to be in great physical shape doing it. Vamos Rafa!

If you win Wimbledon you're destined to be the Best. Which Federer has done many times.

@John Walker, I could not have put it better, but with English not being my 1st language, I do battle sometimes to find the right words.

Very well written comment by you. Great. Thanks

Both Rafa And Roger Are Great Players!

It is absurd to compare them both at this time, when one is younger than the other. Wait until both leave the game and them we can match the numbers. Rafa has a long way to go and Fed has got much less time, can Rafa stay on top as Fed did? Can he win more Slams than Fed? Will he be injury free as Fed is until now?? We need to wait!

One thing is for certain, if someone respects Fed in the game, is Rafa, not just because of his accomplishments but because he is humble as well! Let's not forget what Fed has done for the game!

Stop creating non-sense comparisons now, even Rafa doesn't like to be compraed to Fed because it is just not right at this moment!
Instead of putting pleayers down, Let's hope that Fed keeps it up and keeps winning and as well as for Rafa. It's what's best for the game!

Thank You!

Congratulations Rafael to get the 4 grand slams. That is truly great, you are amazing, I do congratulate your from my heart for the US Open. I wish you more more record ahead. Again Congratulations.

rafa at the moment is the best player in the world winning the US open is just a great accomplishment, its to early to say that his the best but definite one of the best hope he will be free of injuries in the coming years congratz RAFA.

I grew up watching Conners, Bjorg, Lendl and McEnroe but what I saw during this US Open was somehow beyond tennis. Nadal is the best I've ever seen and his humility makes him a true sportsman.

Roger can learn a bit of humility from Rafa. I used to be a huge Roger fan and now I am terribly disappointed at many of the interviews in which he feels a need to "intimidate emotionally" his opponents. Hands down, Rafa does not feel a need to stoop to such pathetic proportions.

Not even if Rafa surpasses Federer on tournaments accomplished, will he ever be better. Rog's style and grace on court are unmatchable. Where I think he has opportunities to improve, will be his humbleness...definitely Rog needs to conquer his bad temper whenever he losses. But when it comes to mental power, physical resistance, style (one of the best backhands EVER)... The Goat will always be the KING of Tennis....!!!!!

Vamos Rafa!!!!!!!!! Nadal is a great player not only great but very humble, polite and well mannered. When you compare Federer to Nadal, Nadal is still the best in terms of character and humility. Federer is full of himself too much. RAFA is my idol!!!!!!! go go go Rafa we love you.

rafa you are the best from the rest... the philippines love your game and your character on and off the court... mabuhay ka!

As a huge Nadal fan, I have to too agree with Rafa. Roger is the best ever to play the game and a wizzard with his wand. Rafa has a chance to be the best ever, but he must win 16 Slams which if his knees can hold out. Well done Rafa !!!

Rafa is young, humble, hardworking, athletic and he is to Tenis what Arsenal is to football: good entertainer who gives u value for your money. At 24, he will overtake Rogers by the time he clocks 29.

It's hard to compare stars from different eras because the size and physical conditioning of the players and the technology available is so vastly different than it was back in the day. What, for example, would Jimmy Connors have done using 21st century racket technology? How much better would John McEnroe have been if he'd been as fit as Nadal or Murray? What more might Borg have achieved on the
hi-tech surfaces of today? Comparing Nadal and Federer is also a bit tough. They are contemporaries but they're overlapping contempories due to the difference in age. I feel Nadal's reaching his peak as Federer is in decline. Had they both been at their peak at the same time drawing comparisons would have been more valid. I think tennis fans should just be grateful that somone is picking up the Federer mantle because, aside from Nadal, there is no superstar on the men's tour to get really excited about.

Well, I think that Rafa deserves his number one; however, he has to win some more grand slam titles to be considered the greatest tennis player. Rafa is terrific and his opponents will have to do something extraordinary to bit him. Vamos Rafa!!

I think Rafa might just fall short of being the best ever. Not so sure if he can consistently deiver on the hard court Grand Slams (US and Australian Open). Yes, he's still young and with many years of tennis to come. However, to be the best ever is a big statement and it is very dependent on how Rafa's knees can hold up during the prime of his career.

Am passionate about tennis.I would not compare Rafa 2 Rooger just yet. Even Rafa knows and is humble about. Rafa has what it takes to "the Man" in tennis but until then give to Roger. He is such beauty to watch.

I believe Nadal will achieve even more in the future...

Nadal is the man of the moment i luv ur style of play keep it up.

roger federer is the best tennis player in the world~~

Whilst Rafa is a good player when he is on form it is obvious that the best tennis player in the World is Roger Federer – his greatness is not only in tennis but all the other attributes 6 languages, plays many sports including football (EnglishA), golf, has created many schools – not talkd about much – through his Foundation in South Africa – is polite, kind, courteous and try watching his behaviour with ball girls/boys remember he was one as well.

Yes cold be the best

Been a fan of Rafa since before his first grand slam win.

A great time for tennis, Rafa falls in a small percentage of high profile really likeable professional athletes. It is great to have such a person as a role model for my kids, there are so few around.

All the best Rafa, whether you win 9 or 20 Grand Slams, you're an inspiration.

Rafael Nadal has age on his side. If he keeps fit one does not see what will prevent him from being the best ever. Good luck to the young Spaniard.

Hello All..

Rafa is definitely one among the greatest to have ever played the game and my favourite player.

If you want to go by numbers, I dont think he would go beyond Federer's slam count due to fitness reasons. He needs to be more selective with the tournaments he participates in esp the ATP tournaments in order to prolong is career and not disappoint fans like us all over the globe.

Vamos Rafa! Watch out for Andy Murray in the semis in London .